Postmodernity, Hermeneutics, and the Second Naïveté

Updated 4 months ago

Source: http://theimageoffish.com/

This morning, Tony Jones published on his blog the contents of a chapter he wrote for The Justice Project. In it he discusses the utility of some aspects of postmodern thought to the faithful Christian.  His particular consideration of Hans-Georg Gadamer and Paul Ricoeur and the hermeneutic of humility prompted me to add on to some thoughts I started in my comments of the transforming possibility of text.  I have been engaged by the work of Paul Ricoeur since I first read him, and I imagine I’ll ...

  • 14 comments on this story
PRO

50% positive

Showing 10 relevant reactions out of 14.

Hello Callid,

Sorry the for the delay in response. This idea of the “text to be lived” is my general impression of monastics. I’ve garnered this conclusion from books such as Frank Bianco’s Voices of Silence: Lives of the Trappists Today, and Nancy Maguire’s stunning book An Infinity of Little Hours. In addition, you may peruse Adrian House’s wonderful biography
... See all content

4 months ago by Greg on Wordpress

@ Greg I’m glad that you found some clarity here. That is one of my main focuses here, to provide folks with accessible options to great thinkers.

Your perspective on monasticism is interesting, any place I might read more about the idea that “the text is meant to be lived in its fullest extent (re: the idea you pose on the congregant living the story, or seeing/interpreting how
... See all content

4 months ago by Callid on Wordpress

Callid,

Thank you for the post. I have always been confused by the term hermeneutics, and things are certainly more clear than before.

Thomas Merton touched on this in a journal entry from May of 1949:

“God makes us ask ourselves questions most often when He tends to resolve them…any perplexity is liable to be a spiritual gestation leading to new birth and a
... See all content

4 months ago by Greg on Wordpress

[...] This post was Twitted by Theopoetics [...]

4 months ago by Twitted by Theopoetics on Wordpress

Social comments and analytics for this post…

This post was mentioned on Twitter by theimageoffish: Inspired by a Tony Jones blog entry: new post about Paul Ricoeur, The Second Naivete, and Christian application: http://ow.ly/CW1O…

4 months ago by uberVU - social comments on Wordpress

@ Matt Thanks for the compliment. The whole reason I am engaged in this work is that even though I am an academic at (or near) heart, the suffering I experience around me is sometimes more than I can bear, and the fact that the Church sometimes is part of its cause… well, anything I can do to provide new views and help to folks is what I feel called to do. Postmodern thought has a powerful perspective ... See all content

4 months ago by Callid on Wordpress

>@theimageoffish: new post about Paul Ricoeur, The Second Naivete, and Christian application: http://ow.ly/CW1O // great video! #f

4 months ago by blakehuggins on Twitter

Inspired by a Tony Jones blog entry: new post about Paul Ricoeur, The Second Naivete, and Christian application: http://ow.ly/CW1O

4 months ago by theimageoffish on Twitter

I love Ricoeur’s line at the end of The Symbolism of Evil, something along the lines of “after the desert of modern criticism we yearn to be called again.”

More than anything, I wish the church — progressive theologians in particular — would get over their romance with the modern, historical-critical method and start engaging the likes of Gadamer and Ricoeur.
... See all content

4 months ago by Blake Huggins on Wordpress

I’m fast becoming a huge fan of the way you boil some of postmodernism’s ideas down to applicable levels, as most postmodern thought is really very practical (despite its tendency to be fairly unaccessible). I might recommend this video to a group of friends who I meet with to discuss postmodern Christianity sometime in the next few weeks. I’ll let you know how it goes, if you’re ... See all content

4 months ago by Matthew Gallion on Wordpress

© uberVU Ltd. 2010

Terms of use
FEEDBACK